I’ve never been a fan of that rule. Good players still go from small clubs (CCM) to big clubs all the time, but the small team gets nothing out of the deal. I can’t see how it wouldn’t benefit the smaller clubs more than the big ones, who would almost certainly end up paying overs for emerging and slightly-above-average talent.
I’m quite sure that @himmelblau is right about the transfer fee thing. I don’t know whether it was actually a rule or not, but it was definitely something reported in the media way back, and was also in my understanding still in effect.
Not the loan rules, not the ban on domestic transfer fees; but that transfer fees were included in the salary cap.
My understanding was that without it you could trivially make transfer arrangements where part of the fee is paid by the selling club to the player to make them willing to accept an unrealistically low in-cap salary at the HAL club.
Its such a shame for him that his off-season was so disrupted, because it looked like a good and trouble-free 2018/19 season could’ve seen him go overseas. He would be absolutely mad to go to the Wanderers. Such a step down.
As a kid running around in Bunburry he often dreamt about playing for the most ambitious, passionately supported and biggest club in Australia. His dreams of this always had him in a green kit playing in Melbourne.